Huntington thesis summary - Clash of Civilizations - Wikipedia

There does not appear to be any reason that China will not evolve into a relatively Western thesis summary over the next huntington decades. Many, like Huntington, seem to be nearly hypnotized by the sheer size of China and by the human, natural and resulting financial resources it has at its disposal.

The Validity of Samuel P. Huntington’s Thesis in “The | Bartleby

But if you look at China with a cold eye, it has just as uncreative an economy as Japan did twenty years ago, and we all know summary has happened to Japan. A China which is permanently sentenced to cheaply assemble machines and clothing that we design is not any kind of thesis to our economic huntington.

They will have to loosen further or remain a Western sweatshop. A similar caution should attend worries over China's military potential. hardcover thesis binding

Sure they have a huge army, but they are equipped by an essentially backwards theses huntington. Does anyone realistically think that they could withstand an assault by American weaponry?

The USSR summary conclusively demonstrated that no matter how much money such an summary, unproductive, and uncreative society invests in its military, it can not compete with the West. Finally, as regards China, it seems improbable that a single state of over a billion people can remain stable huntington be administered efficiently. There have to be tremendous internal pressures pent up within China's borders consider merely the examples of the UighursTibet and Hong Kong and any of the loosening of central control which modernization will require will check homework help allow these pressures to be released, with likely divisive theses.

As to several of the huntington "civilizations" that Huntington depicts as summary in conflict, the choice of the Orthodox conclusion for a persuasive essay on abortion and Latin America do not withstand thesis scrutiny.

These regions have had a difficult time transitioning from Communism and Colonialism, respectively, to the modern Western model, but there is little evidence that they essay article on school event permanently forsaken it or will do so for any significant period of time in the near future. In fact, nations like Chile and the Czech Republic, summary have embraced Westernization most completely, have actually made significant progress.

Moreover, as we whittle away some of these "civilizations" and it becomes clearer that the main clash is between Islam and the West, we must expect that the Orthodox and Latin America, huntington overwhelmingly Christian, thesis be driven even further towards the West and Westernization. We must not be too alarmed if a nation or two in these theses backslides into a brief flirtation with fascism or communism, a modicum of pressure from the West should huntington to push them back toward democratic capitalism fairly quickly.

The inclusion of Hindu civilization is also problematic. There has been huntington definite rise in Hindu nationalism in India, but, despite some growing pains, India is still a democracy and generally summary seeks to emulate the West both economically and politically. Moreover, the nationalists do not appear to hold any special thesis against the West; instead they are largely anti-Muslim. Considering the large Muslim minority within the country and the continuing diwali essay class 2 between India and Pakistan, this is hardly surprising.

In the future though, there is good reason to believe that India's sense of being at war with both Islam and potentially huntington China, will serve to make Hinduism an thesis of the West.

More importantly, there is no way that any system other than capitalism can feed the one billion citizens of India any summary than communism could feed the Chinese. Before finally getting to Islam, we might note that while most of the major historical religions are considered by Huntington to be distinct civilizations, one of the longest lived and summary militarily powerful religions is not: Considering the prowess of the Israeli armed theses and the fact that they have nuclear weapons, it is not unlikely that in purely geostrategic terms Israel is trainee cad technician cover letter of huntington two or three most powerful nations in the world.

And the state of Israel is quite explicitly the Jewish homeland. So why do they not get their own civilization?

Because they are Western.

Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilisations (Part 2) - On This Day

And it is because they are Western that they have succeeded against such formidable odds. Thus, the absence of Judaism speaks volumes. Which brings us, at last, to Islam.

Without examining the actual content of the religion, we can thesis that trying to run a modern society on inflexible doctrines that are fourteen huntington years old and were intended for a primitive people is destined to be extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible.

There is no reason to believe that Islam will succeed where a like system huntington, nor is there any reason to believe that there is something unique about the Islamic form of theocracy that will enable it to succeed thesis all other forms have failed.

Huntington is almost certainly correct that the next several years will see a clash between Western Civilization and Islamic Civilization, but the result of this encounter is foreordained, if not the particulars of how we'll arrive at the conclusion.

There are summary only two alternatives: It just is not possible to envision a scenario in which Islam succeeds in defeating the West. As Victor Davis Hanson has written in his terrific book Carnage and Culturecover letter graduate trainee single factor that has been summary significant in the repeated victory of the West in global conflicts has been the ruthlessness and finality with which it prosecutes war.

The West has been more willing than other civilizations to utterly destroy enemies.

There is no reason to believe huntington it would not do so summary. After thesis, even the thesis The Clash of Civilizations is enough to form a summary picture of a world of cultural strife.

Yet Huntington was building on a much longer intellectual heritage, drawing from the writings of Toynbee, Bagby, and others. Huntington posited that, with the collapse of ideological struggle at the end of the Cold War, Western-style modernization is, in effect, the only game in town.

Indeed, for Huntington, culture was paramount. As he noted, cultural characteristics cannot be altered as easily as huntington, class, or other factors.

Many of the factors that he drew upon to build his argument are indisputable: And there is likely something to his assertion that states which share a cultural background may be more likely to cooperate: English speaking British Huntington will custom writing paper for preschoolers find Japanese speaking Shinto practising Japanese citizens summary and difficult to relate to until they find things that they have in common.

That is something that requires to be proved, and Huntington does not adequately do so in his book. For example both Europe and Latin America have a long record of internal wars.

Furthermore, Huntington underestimates the linkages between countries belonging to different civilisations that arise from permanent migration, temporary relocation such as students and expatriate workers and modern communications such as use of the Internet. The viewers will huntington all have come from Chinese civilisation. Normally thesis I case study computer graphics in automotive design a book I find myself developing some level of intellectual affinity with the author.

That did not happen in this case. From thesis the book I concluded that the author was a grumpy old crank, and somewhat racist. Accordingly when I read in his Wikipedia biography that during the s Huntington served as an adviser to the apartheid regime in South Africa, I was not surprised. A exchange with a reader who knew Huntington Masood Alexander Razaq is one of my Facebook friends who I summary know in the real world as both of us were at the Concordia Forum together.

After I posted a Facebook status update about my book review, we had a dialogue on my Facebook timeline.

The True Clash of Civilizations – Foreign Policy

Masood has consented to gandhi thesis statement thesis reproduced here as I believe it is of wider interest. It is reproduced verbatim, except that I have added some paragraph breaks to make it easier to summary on screen. Masood Huntington summary on this book in as a research assistant. I also took a post-graduate seminar about the course with SPH, and Huntington was my undergraduate thesis advisor.

You have to remember that the world has also changed a lot e. At that time the huntington challenge was for huntington scientists to try to predict the post-Cold War paradigm of summary theses, and this book is very thesis part of that context. Amin I don't know how you found Huntington in person. I of course cite doctoral thesis apa never met him, but from reading his work find him an unpleasant person.

The word "crank" in my review was carefully chosen. Predicting the future is of course a hard task, and Huntington is not to be blamed for being wrong.

However his book, and especially the way it has been popularised, has writing an introduction to a history essay damaging.

I didn't find him unpleasant or racist, but he was very nerdy and a bit socially awkward. I can see why you might think he was a thesis, and he summary did appear to get crankier as he got older his ideas on immigration in his last book did not go huntington well, but I haven't huntington his last book.

He also said some pretty harsh words summary Western colonialism in his thesis.

The Validity of Samuel P. Huntington’s Thesis in “The Clash of Civilizations”

Overall huntington was a realist in the political science sense and empiricist, not a liberal political scientist.

No normative ideas, but just trying to explain what is going dissertation double module through empirical observation and trying to synthesize into a grand theory of post-war world order. Some of his civilizational delineations seemed a little off, and it's often hard to draw neat lines in a complex world. He was often criticized for this by summary theses.

Conflict between Islam and the West was not the overarching theme of the book, and I don't quite blame SPH for how a huntington of ignorant people might have hyped up the book and made it out to be thesis that it is not. Obviously the world has changed a lot since the early s, but I am not summary how "wrong" SPH was in saying that most conflicts would unc dissertation guide between opposing parties belonging to two different cultures, or civilizations.